PDA

View Full Version : Dundee United Sack Alex Smith


Shed Boy
Oct 7 2002, 11:19 AM
I cannot beleive this, I was calling for his head, did not think he would actually go until rumours started flying about last night that his job was under threat.

Alex Smith has been sacked by Dundee United two games into the reign of new owner Eddie Thompson.
The announcement was made at a Monday media conference held 24 hours after BBC Scotland disclosed that Thompson had decided a change was necessary at the top.

And Falkirk boss Ian McCall and Inverness Caledonian Thistle manager Steve Paterson have emerged as favourites to be Smith's successor.

Former Dundee United and Scotland defender Richard Gough is also believed to be interested.

But there is no chance that his former boss at Rangers, Walter Smith, will be appointed at Tannadice.


United boss Alex Smith was under pressure


Millionaire grocer Thompson denied it was a kneejerk reaction, coming after two defeats since he completed his takeover last month left United second bottom of the Scottish Premier League.

"There's no question that this has been pretty tough decision, but I've been watching what the club has been doing and how the manager has been doing and formulating my own ideas for some time," he said.

"I stated that if we didn't start picking up the points then action would be taken.

"The Premier League table doesn't lie. I said I would judge it on performances and see how results went.

"The manager has been with us two and a quarter years and during that time I can't remember missing two games."

Newspaper reports have already suggested that McCall has been approached to take over from Smith.

Thompson insists that nobody from United has talked with the former Bradford, Dunfermline and Rangers winger.

But the new United chairman is known to have a preference for a "younger, hungrier man" to take over from seasoned campaigner Smith.

Smith led unfashionable St Mirren to the Scottish Cup before heading for Aberdeen, where many believe he was unfairly dismissed for not being able to match the record of Sir Alex Ferguson.

But Smith's record of 31 wins in 99 matches since moving to Tannadice does not make impressive reading.

While some on the board may wish to turn to former United defender Walter Smith, who has since gone on to manage Rangers and Everton, such an appointment is unlikely.


Ian McCall has had continuous success

Smith is believed to want to continue his career in England and would probably come more expensive than United's budget.

As United have no cash to buy players, it would also be a different kind of job to those Smith has experienced before, when he had large sums to deal with at Goodison and Ibrox.

He himself dismissed the possibility of taking over at Tannadice and said: "I find it a bit sad as Alex has had four chairman and had no stability at the club."

Gough is another with strong Tannadice connections, but the former Everton and Tottenham Hotspur defender does not have the coaching experience for which Thompson would be looking.

McCall has proven himself capable of building teams against the odds at Clydebank, Airdrieonians and now Falkirk.

He has turned a side only saved last season from relegation by Airdrieonians' liquidation into runaway leaders of the First Division.

Paterson led equally cash-strapped Caley Thistle all the way from the Highland League to consolidation in the First Division.



From BBC Scotland

ArabChris
Oct 7 2002, 01:34 PM
well mate
i can believe this
it has been coming
thanks for all the work alex but its about time you were gone mate
so whos in line for new job?
richard gough?
ian mccall?
walter smith?
paul hegarty?
malpas?
who knows

Shed Boy
Oct 7 2002, 10:06 PM
I hope it's Paterson, deserves his chance but I can see if being Ian McCall. Cant see Gough or W.Smith and please for the love of god not Heggie or Mo, they are great servents to the club but could not manage the club.

And good luck to smith in the future.

ArabChris
Oct 8 2002, 12:41 PM
yep good luck smithy, he had time to say thanks for the fans after being released and i appreciate that

as for manager choice, looks as if mccall is main target
cant see w.smith or gough joining
as you said mate pls not mo or hegarty, important to the club but not as a manger surely

but who knows

eddie thompson certainly has his mind set on replacing smith within the next few days

i admire eddie thompson for what he is doing, he has been brave enough to not even be two weeks in the job and he is looking at it from a supporters view i believe

Manic Loop
Oct 8 2002, 10:19 PM
what went wrong with him then? bad management or bad luck?
i always keep an eye on dundee united, alays liked them for some reason

Shed Boy
Oct 9 2002, 11:03 AM
Well beasically he was the saviour when he came in, we where as good as relegated, about 9 points or something at about christmas, until he turned it around and we were saved.

But he really could not take us much further than that , and It was kinda just time for change. He has a very bad tactical knowledge. A bad habit of playing players out of position. Also he always waited too long to make substitutions if we were gettin beat.



Now we could be up shit creek without a paddle, McCall is staying at Falkirk, and Inverness fans seem adiment that Paterson wont come to Tannadice.

Please for the love of god, not Heggie and Mo!!!!

Blue
Oct 9 2002, 11:29 AM
Richard Gough might be a good choice.

Shed Boy
Oct 9 2002, 11:31 AM
Richard Gough might be a good choice.


I seriously doubt that. I dont think that he would come either. Better of with someone with a little bit of managerial experience.

Blue
Oct 9 2002, 11:47 AM
How about Stuart McCall or Tommy Burns?
(they might be tempted to take over)

ArabChris
Oct 9 2002, 01:41 PM
cant say i fancy any of the above apart from walter smith
mccall is a NO now
i thought about peter reid
ET says "i want a bright young enthuasiastic manager"
isnt this what he is?

Manic Loop
Oct 9 2002, 03:57 PM
i thought youd want to stick with someone from north of the border

ArabChris
Oct 9 2002, 04:02 PM
yeh mate but the people eddie thompson r looking at are of lower divisions
which i dont like!
we should be aiming our sights bit higher, were a big club and deserve a decent manager

Shed Boy
Oct 9 2002, 08:24 PM
There isnt really much differences between the divisions now though really is there. nobody has any money to spend and I beleive that Paterson now would be the best appointment we woulc hope for. ET als said that internal options were still being looked at.