Kevin Phillips or Kenny Miller?

[James de Bear]

Reports in the papers suggest it's between these two players who will partner Prso, but who would you choose?

I would go for Phillips and with Arteta going now we'll have the money to get him.

[Dandy]

Reports in the papers suggest it's between these two players who will partner Prso, but who would you choose?

I would go for Phillips and with Arteta going now we'll have the money to get him.

Phillips. I'd even try an attempt to get Beattie.

I still think Prso is the biggest mistake ever. He was only a Sunday-league player about 6 years ago and he's 29. Think about it.

[England_04]

thought you lads already has miller?

[coatsy]

Phillips. I'd even try an attempt to get Beattie.

I still think Prso is the biggest mistake ever. He was only a Sunday-league player about 6 years ago and he's 29. Think about it.


scored a few in the champions league,doesn't matter what he was doing a few years ago,it's what he's doing now that matters.forget philips or beattie,we can't afford to pay nacho novo ,how are we going to pay a player used to big wages in the english premiership?

[mood]

Kevin Phillips is much better than Miller. He was scored 30 Premiership goals like 3 seasons ago.

[Ross]

I'd prefer to see Kevin Phillips at Rangers

[webber137]

I dont think rangers desperately need another striker, thompson or averladze should be given the chance to partner prso. If rickson goes, i think rangers should pull khizanishvilli up as a defensive midfielder (his preferred position).

[Gunners/Gers]

thought you lads already has miller?

Miller left in Mcleishs first year after being out on loan i think.

Id much prefer Phillips as hes a proven goalscorer and thats what we need.

[Dandy]

scored a few in the champions league,doesn't matter what he was doing a few years ago,it's what he's doing now that matters.forget philips or beattie,we can't afford to pay nacho novo ,how are we going to pay a player used to big wages in the english premiership?

Those goals were a once in a lifetime affair. I was listening to some comments made by McCoist about Prso and he think that he's overrated because of that flukey night. He's not a solution to the club's problems.

[rangersmad]

both players looked to have bags of potental when they were younger but havn't done much this season. Novo is a much better option.

[BanRay]

Phillips

[Dandy]

Has anyone else clued into the fact that Phillips is also 31 years old?

[Ross420]

I cant understand why Soton would sell one of their best players when its hard for a club like that to sign quality, but the Phillips rumour has been doing the rounds here for ages and wont go away.

If there is any truth in it then its simply a question of how much the fee is. Phillips is a great goalscorer but hes not 21 and Rangers cant afford big fees for players with zero sell-on potential.

As for Kenny Miller, why the feck did we sell him to begin with? :rolleyes:

[colpol]

wolves are relegated so miller would be cheap , bout the same as novo

[TrueBlue]

It's got to be Phillips out of the two :clap

[James de Bear]

Looks like it's Phillips as papers ar reporting that from the sale of Arteta we will spend some of it on Phillips.

[Dandy]

He's freakin' 31 people!

[Ross]

another one to add to the injury list then maybe? as it seems the older players are more prone to injurys

[James de Bear]

He's freakin' 31 people!

doesn't matter, aslong as he bangs the goals in he can be 61 for all I care

[Dandy]

In the current financial situation, would you rather spend money on a player who we can buy who's 21-22, have for the long-term? Then spending money on a player who will only be around for 3 years at most.

[Ross420]

He's freakin' 31 people!

Fredi Bobic is 41 and still going strong :devil

[colpol]

phillips would be a waste of money , stick to novo and **** phillips and miller off , kenny had his chance and didn't impress. stay in div 1.

[Dandy]

Fredi Bobic is 41 and still going strong :devil

Bobic did **** all this season for us. He managed to score like 3-4 goals total. Meyer benched him as soon as he took over.

[colpol]

and yet bobic is germans main striker threat in euro 2004 !!!! hahahaha

[colpol]

southampton rejected a bid from rangers for phillips. didn't say how much the bid was just that southampton weren't a "selling club". probbly about 3-4 mil pounds my quess.

[James de Bear]

From the papars it says rangers made an equiry not a bid but were told they weren't selling.